FUDforum: General Chit Chat » Comparison of FUD vs phpBB etc

Home » General » General Chit Chat » Comparison of FUD vs phpBB etc (We're looking for some forum software)

Show: Today's Messages :: Unread Messages :: Show Polls :: Message Navigator
| Subscribe to topic | Bookmark topic

Comparison of FUD vs phpBB etc [message #161662]

Tue, 26 January 2010 00:37

JeffB

Messages: 10
Registered: January 2010
Location: US

Karma: 0

Junior Member

add to buddy list
ignore all messages by this user

Hello,

I'm a moderator on a discussion forum which was running vBulletin. It's crashed a number of times and I think the owners are likely to bail on the site.

A number of the mods who have been running the show for several years set up a temporary site which came with phpBB 2.xx software preinstalled.

I personally prefer the threaded view which is not available on phpBB and apparently never will be. That's one advantage it would seem to me with FUD. Are there others? We're in the process of trying to upgrade to the phpBB 3.xx version but maybe we'd be better off with FUD.

Are there any drawbacks with FUD vs. phpBB?

One issue that has caused us problems in the past were drive by spammers and bots. I believe the newer version of phpBB is supposed to stop a lot of that. So is the ability of making the membership list viewable only by members. That will supposedly cut down on folks who just sign up to post a link to their website(s) to help get a little more traffic and perhaps a better listing on rating engines.

Is that hiding of the membership list an option with FUD?

Does the "Captcha" work well in stopping the bots?

Thanks in advance for any help or insights anyone may be able to provide.

Report message to a moderator

Rate author: +1 -1

Re: Comparison of FUD vs phpBB etc [message #161664 is a reply to message #161662]

Tue, 26 January 2010 04:56

naudefj

Messages: 3266
Registered: December 2004

Karma: 6

Senior Member
Administrator
Core Developer

add to buddy list
ignore all messages by this user

JeffB wrote:

Are there any drawbacks with FUD vs. phpBB?

Besides any obscure features, FUDforum should be able to do anything phpBB can do. If it cannot, I would very much like to know so it can be added to the next release.

JeffB wrote:

Is that hiding of the membership list an option with FUD?

Absolutely, it was added years ago:

Hide user profiles:
If enabled, anonymous and unconfirmed forum members will not be able to view profiles of registered users.

JeffB wrote:

Does the "Captcha" work well in stopping the bots?

On it's own, maybe not, but in conjunction with spambot detection, flood control, etc. you should be OK.

Best regards.

Frank

Report message to a moderator

Rate author: +1 -1

Re: Comparison of FUD vs phpBB etc [message #161672 is a reply to message #161664]

Tue, 26 January 2010 23:19

JeffB

Messages: 10
Registered: January 2010
Location: US

Karma: 0

Junior Member

add to buddy list
ignore all messages by this user

Thanks.

I really like the ability to be able to toggle back and forth between the tree view and the flat view.

It looks like the link button is a lot easier to use than adding a link in the phpB 2.xx version anyway. I usually had to click on the link to go to the bbcode page, copy the code for a link and then paste it in my message, then paste the link and then the text. The phpBB is easy enough if it's just a link, but if you want text that is different than the link several additional steps are needed.

Thanks again!

Report message to a moderator

Rate author: +1 -1

Thanks a lot for all of your work on this software [message #161754 is a reply to message #161662]

Tue, 02 February 2010 18:37

JeffB

Messages: 10
Registered: January 2010
Location: US

Karma: 0

Junior Member

add to buddy list
ignore all messages by this user

It looks like we'll be converting our older phpBB forum sometime this week.

One of the moderators set up a copy of the FUD Forum software for us in a "sandbox" and copied the database from the other forum for us to play in and experiment with. He did the same for the newest version of phpBB so we could evaluate them side by side.

So far, of the moderators who have responded, they all liked the FUD Forum software better.

As an aside, the guy who set it up for us didn't like the name. He used to work at IBM and FUD stood for a rather unsavory practice of trying to instill "Fear Uncertainty and Doubt" in customers minds if they were to try and switch computer systems to a competitor.

But over all, we are happy so far with the software and like many of the features and things you have done with it. The ability to put icons to the left of the individual forums is another nice touch, btw. It really jazzes up the site and probably helps members navigate a little more quickly to a forum they may be looking for. Or at least that is our hope.

I suppose we'll find out soon enough.

Report message to a moderator

Rate author: +1 -1

Re: Thanks a lot for all of your work on this software [message #161803 is a reply to message #161754]

Sun, 07 February 2010 15:43

kerryg

Messages: 155
Registered: September 2008

Karma: 0

Senior Member

add to buddy list
ignore all messages by this user

LOL - yeah, the name has been an occasional topic of debate.

After all three of my phpBB forums were spammed, hacked and flooded to death, I moved them one at a time to FUDforum. I have not had a single solitary spam in a year. You couldn't pay me to go back.

From my end-user's perspective, FUDforum seems *vastly* easier to secure than phpBB. The one drawback back then was that it was harder to set up than phpBB, but with recent updates it's become no-brainer easy.

[Updated on: Sun, 07 February 2010 15:45]

Report message to a moderator

Rate author: +1 -1